WHY WOULD TWO BATCHES AT THE SAME pH HAVE DIFFERENT TASTES?

WHY WOULD TWO BATCHES AT THE SAME pH HAVE DIFFERENT TASTES?

Understanding the Difference between pH and Perceived Acidity
It is a very common – and often confusing – situation in products such as sauces, dairy drinks, fruit spreads, and fermented foods: two batches measure exactly the same pH, yet they taste noticeably different. One may seem sharper, flatter, or more rounded than the other.
The reason is simple but important: ph is not the same as how sour a product taste. Below is a clear, practical explanation that can be shared with production teams, quality staff, or even customers.

pH Measures Acid Strength, Not Total Sourness
pH measures the strength of acidity, specifically the activity of hydrogen ions in a product. It tells us how acidic something is from a chemical and safety perspective.
However, perceived sourness is how much acid is present overall and how your taste buds experience it.
This means two products can both measure pH 3.5, yet one may taste far more acidic than the other. The pH number alone does not capture the full flavour experience.

Different Acids Taste Different (even at the same pH)
Not all acids are perceived the same by the human palate. Even when adjusted to the same pH, different acids create very different profiles:
• Citric Acid: sharp, bright, immediate sourness,
• Acetic Acid (vinegar): harsh, lingering, sometimes nasal,
• Malic Acid: smooth, rounded, long-lasting,
• Lactic Acid: mild, creamy, soft acidic.
As a result, one batch formulated mainly with citric acid and another using more vinegar can have the same pH but completely different taste intensity and character.

Buffering Ingredients Change Acid Perception
Certain ingredients ‘buffer’ or soften acidity without significantly changing pH. These ingredients interact with acids and reduce how aggressively they are perceived on the tongue.
Common buffering components include:
• Starches,
• Proteins,
• Tomato solids,
• Gums such as CMC or Xanthan,
• Minerals like salt or calcium.
A sauce with more starch or protein will often taste less sour, even if the pH reading is identical to a thinner or less buffered product.

Sugar and Salt Mask Acidity
Sweetness and saltiness strongly influence how sour a product tastes:
• Sugar suppresses sourness,
• Salt reduces sharp acid edges.
For example, two batches at pH 3.5 can taste very different if:
• Batch A contains more sugar and tastes rounder and softer.
• Batch B contains less sugar and tastes sharper and more acidic.
This is why pH control alone cannot guarantee consistent flavour.

Temperature Affects Taste Perception
Temperature plays a surprisingly large role in acidity perception:
• Cold products taste less acidic.
• Warm products taste more acidic.
If one batch was tasted warm and another cold, they will not taste the same – even with identical pH values. Consistent tasting temperature is essential for reliable sensory comparison.

Timing of Acidic Addition Matters
When acid is added during processing, it also affects the flavour:
• Acid added early can bind with starches or proteins,
• Acid added late remains ‘freer’ and more noticeable.
Two products may end at the same pH, but the one with late acid addition often tastes sharper and more intense due to greater free acidity.

pH Meters Are Not Taste Buds
A pH meter measures chemistry. Humans, however, experience:
• Total acidity,
• Type of acid,
• Balance with sugar, salt, and texture.
“Same pH does not mean the same flavour.”

Key Takeaway
“pH tells us how safe the product is, but flavour depends on the type of acid, sugar balance, and how the ingredients interact”

Typical QA Tip for Consistent Flavour
To achieve consistent taste from batch to batch:
• Control acid type and ratios, not just final pH,
• Set acid formulations, not only pH specifications,
• Always conduct tasting at the same temperature.
Understanding these factors helps bridge the gap between laboratory measurements and real-world sensory quality – ensuring products are not only safe, but consistently delicious.

    • Related Articles

    • IMPORTANCE OF PH METER IN DAIRY PRODUCTION

      Accurate monitoring of pH is essential during production of various dairy products to ensure that the control parameters in the food safety program are being achieved. The type of pH meter selected must be fit for purpose and capable of accurately ...

    • LOOKING INTO THE DIFFERENCES BETWEEN TWO PECTIN TYPES: PECTIN MRS 351 VERSUS IDEALPETIN HMR 101

      When comparing two popular pectin types, Pectin MRS 351 and IdealPectin HMR 101, it is important to closely examine their key differences. First and foremost, Pectin MRS 351 is widely recognized for its high gel strength properties, making it an ...

    • CAN I HAVE SOME MORE INFORMATION REGARDING THE PRODUCTION OF LOW FAT CHEESE?

      Are you a cheese lover who also values a healthy lifestyle? Well, you'll be delighted to discover the wonders of low fat cheese production! With advancements in technology and a growing focus on health, low fat cheese has become a popular choice for ...

    • HOW DO I SOLVE BITTERNESS IN CHEESE?

      Cheese bitterness is a complex problem to solve. It starts with your raw milk quality…. It’s more common in Gouda than Cheddar. Attached are some suggestions and more information in addressing this issue. Furthermore a person could also consider ...

    • WHAT ARE THE DIFFERENT TYPES OF DAIRY ALTERNATIVES?

      Some people need to avoid dairy products and cows' milk because their bodies cannot digest lactose (lactose intolerance) or they have an allergy to cows' milk protein. There are a number of lactose-free dairy products available to buy that are ...